• Home
  • From Rushen with love...
  • Media
  • About
  • Contact
  • Archive
    • 2026 Campaign >
      • 2026 Manifesto
      • Pledges
    • 2021 Archive
  Michelle Haywood

From Rushen with love...




Politics is a messy business; a world where tradition, legislation and personalities collide with varying levels of integrity, honesty, self-interest and ability, in order to support collective decision making on behalf of the communities that politicians seek to serve.  

In these posts I will share some of my thoughts about political life and developments in the Isle of Man and further afield.  If you have a suggestion for a topic please let me know.

Categories

All
20mph
Accountable
Chief MInister
Climate Change
Emissions Data
Evidence Based
Good Government
House Of Keys
Immigration
Integrity
Protocol
Scrutiny
Speaker
Speed Limits
Tynwald Structure
Visas

Tynwald's first sitting

19/10/2026

0 Comments

 
Tuesday 20th October sees the first Tynwald sitting of the Thomas administration.  Due to the relative newness of this incarnation of the House of Keys, there are only three questions and one motion for debate. 

The questions come from the Speaker, Mr Ashford, and given that the Speaker is only permitted to ask questions in Tynwald Court, then he will be looking to take full advantage of the limited number of times he can ask oral questions in the parliamentary year. 

I anticipate that the new Keys Members will by now be getting to grips with the Register of Business and we will see some written and oral questions from them to the new Ministers popping up in due course.  The challenge is to try and write the questions in the ‘house style’ which is a skill in itself.  Once questions are submitted via the Members’ portal on the Tynwald website, the Table Office in Tynwald will advise on changing the wording (without losing the intent) and directing the question to the appropriate Minister or Chair.   Deadlines for getting oral questions submitted for a sitting can be tight, and anyone submitting a question needs to respond to any suggested changes in a timely way or risk missing the deadline.

The best sort of question is one where you already know most of the answer, and you are using the public arena to highlight an area of concern, to gain reassurance from the Minister and some idea of time lines and costings.  Questions that request data are best submitted as written questions, because listening to a Minister read out a data table isn’t the best use of parliamentary time.  Ministers can opt to circulate their answer in advance of a sitting rather than give an overly long answer in Keys or Tynwald.  The Speaker’s tabled questions would indicate that he is seeking to support constituents queries or concerns by highlighting areas where some focus from Ministers is clearly needed and to get the answers out in public. 

Of course, just asking the opening question needs to be followed up with supplementary questions.  This aspect usually takes a bit of time, because you have to think through what sort of response you’re likely to get for the Minister and direct them towards your more specific concern.  The opening question is only ever a warm up for the supplementaries, and other Members can join in on the supplementaries too.  A good brief for a Minister will include trying to guess the supplementary questions and provide the relevant information to allow the Minister to answer.  Two of the Speaker’s questions are directed at the DHSC Minister who is a ‘old hand’ but it will be the first time Mrs Maltby has been in the ‘hot seat’.

Then there’s the motion for debate, which hasn’t had 4 weeks on the Register of Business, so the Court could refuse to debate it at all.  Mr Thomas will be able to explain that there just hasn’t been 4 weeks since the Register was open, but the 4 week delay was built in specifically to allow Members sufficient time to prepare for a debate.  With a heavy induction process and the recent Chief Minister election process having occupied so much of their time, one wonders how much prep they have managed to do for this debate.

However, Mr Thomas’ motion is not a novel motion, as he tried to table the same motion in October 2021:
That Tynwald is of the opinion that the Council of Ministers should publish by the end of November a Government document for debate in Tynwald which sets out a) the current challenges and opportunities that face the Island and b) a prioritised policy agenda, action plan and legislative programme to address them; with annual reviews and revisions being laid for debate and approval each October thereafter.
At the October 2021 sitting, the Chief Minister Alf Cannan observed that he had already committed to publishing an Island Plan during his campaign to be elected as Chief Minister, and that had the motion been heard, then he would have moved to adjourn the debate to November anyway.  Mr Thomas declined to move the motion again in November 2021.

But skip forward to 2026, and here we are again….like Groundhog Day.  The Ard-Sheveishagh has billed the debate as contributing to the new plan for his government, although given that Members only recently produce manifestos, one would assume that he could get a pretty good idea from those documents.  Still, this is an opportunity to Members to get their first long-speech delivered.  I wonder how many AI-provided speeches we will get to hear?

There are quite a few ‘tells’ for an AI-drafted text.  When I was teaching at University I was always on the look out for plagiarised text in essays and reports. It was easy to spot when the sentence structure changed, the vocabulary didn’t fit with the rest of the text and when it was clearly a sentence or paragraph lifted from somewhere else.  To a certain extent you can also spot the same syntax changes in an AI-written version of a speech. 

Various studies have shown that AI is being used more widely in parliaments around the world, in the UK Parliament it has been estimated as over 10% of speeches.  But the spoken word introduces even more opportunities to spot the text that Members didn’t research and craft themselves.  Common AI phrases such as ‘I rise to speak’ are a dead giveaway.  To be honest this is a little like one of my pet hates in a letter “I am writing to…” when I know you are writing because I am reading the damn letter.  In a parliament, when the presiding officer has called on you to speak, you stand to make your contribution.  There’s no need to tell us that is what you are doing. We know.

There are other ‘tells’ that appear in AI-generated speeches.  We all write in a way that matches how we speak, the length of phrases, the construction of sentences and the cadence in our voices.  However, AI doesn’t know how we normally speak (although you could train it), so it’s possible to find words that the speaker never normally uses and will struggle to pronounce, or onomatopoeic clauses that trip up the human tongue.  The words on the page look great, but if they don’t match your normal speaking style you will just look like you are a poor reader. 

Relying on AI-generated speeches feels a little false.  The electorate have selected these Members to play a part in our national parliament and we have high hopes and expectations about their skill at communicating and debating important topics.  Leaving all the ‘thinking and writing’ to an AI agent means that Members may fail to gain a deeper understanding of the topic, missing the nuances from other contributors and not properly politically contextualise their political thoughts.  We didn’t elect anyone to use ChatGPT to run our country.   AI returns an average answer to any task it is given.  We don't want average.  We want insightful, inspiring and intelligent (the real sort not the artificial sort).

Assuming Tynwald Court agrees to let the Ard Sheveishagh table his motion without the time on the Register of Business, tomorrow will be the first time we get to hear Members’ contributions.  I expect all Members will want to speak, after all the debate will be scrutinised for ideas for the new policy agenda. And that agenda will set the direction of the Thomas Government.

It is a little ironic that the motion only promises to publish the agenda by the end of November, meaning that it will miss the deadline for the December sitting and therefore may not be debated until January.  I am sure that for a Government document of such importance, the Ard Shevaishagh will not want to reduce the time that Members have to prepare for the debate by asking the Court to suspend Standing Orders yet again.  It is only right to give Members adequate time to read, consider and to write, edit and craft their own speaking notes for the debate.
​
0 Comments

Voting for a Chief Minister..

6/10/2026

2 Comments

 
So now we know the candidates for Chief Minister, what happens next?

The Speaker has determined that the sitting to nominate a Chief Minister (the election sitting) will take place on Tuesday 13th October.  The Chief Minister’s election will be decided by our 24 Members of the House of Keys.

Before the election sitting
Policy proposals from each candidate were submitted at the same time as nominations. House of Keys Standing Orders requires that policy proposals are published on the Tynwald website, so we will all get to see what sort of proposal each of the candidates is advancing.

Between now and then there will be a hustings for Members to question the candidates.  This won’t take place in the House of Keys Chamber, but is likely to be in the Barool Suite.  Every Member of the House is invited. One assumes they will all attend, and given the importance of selecting the head of executive government if your representative isn’t at the hustings you should be justifiably indignant about it. Already there are patterns of non-attendance at the Tynwald induction sessions emerging. Let’s hope that doesn’t continue.  

All members (including the Speaker) have until noon on the day before the election sitting to submit written questions. Each question is limited to 50 words and the order for questions is drawn at random.  Members can submit more than one question (and they have to rank them in order of importance), but will only end up with one question on the Order paper.  If their name is drawn and there is already a very similar question higher up the Order paper, then they can use their second ranked question instead (or the third etc.).  If they don’t have an alternative question then their original question will be grouped to be asked with similar questions. The pressure is on now for all Members to find at least a couple of sensible, probing questions to challenge those who have put themselves forward for the top job.  Interestingly, the candidates can submit questions too! The Question Paper will be published on the evening before the election sitting.

The Election sitting
For the election sitting, the Speaker will read out the names of the candidates, their nominators and seconders.  Each candidate gets 10 minutes to make an opening speech.  There are a few things to look out for in these speeches.  Their opening speech is a set piece and so one would expect the candidates to be able to speak with confidence, little reference to their notes and to stick within the allotted time.  It’ll be their chance to show how well they connect with the other members, but they need to avoid making grand commitments that they can’t follow through on. 

Then comes the Question Paper.  I am sure many new Members will look forward to their maiden contributions in the House, and everyone will want to contribute to demonstrate to their constituents that they are stepping up to play a full part in our parliament, so expect everyone to have tabled a question.  If your representative hasn’t submitted a question, maybe drop them a line to ask why?

The answers to any question are limited to 3 minutes (or if questions are grouped then an additional minute per additional question).  Questions are asked to both candidates, rotating who gets to answer first.  This is a great opportunity for Members to evaluate the breadth of knowledge and policy consideration from the candidates.  Candidates will have seen the questions the night before - so it’s not quite as spontaneous as the Constituency hustings questions.  One hopes they have done their preparation, but again look out for anyone just reading a pre-prepared script as an answer.

In the event that a candidate has submitted a question, they will also get to answer their own question.  It would be interesting to see this strategy in play, as it provides an excellent set piece opportunity for a candidate to distinguish themselves from the other candidate.  I wonder if either candidate will take up this option?  It’s likely that the candidates will also have ‘planted’ favourable questions, certainly with their nominators and seconders.
Once all the questions have been asked, the candidates get to offer a closing speech of up to 5 minutes.  Look out for clarity of expression, certainty of direction and a clear call for support.

Voting
By this stage it’s safe to assume that both candidates will have at least three votes as generally people do vote for themselves, plus their nominator and seconder.  The Speaker will read out the nominations and invite votes.  Votes are recorded electronically and will be published.

Members of the House of Keys cannot abstain from a vote, they must vote yes or no to each of the candidates.  If they support one, then that’s a yes vote, and they will cast a no for the other candidate. However, if they vote yes to both, or no to both, then their vote will be declared invalid. 

To win, a candidate must get votes from the majority of voting Members present.  On the assumption that all 24 members are present in the Chamber as the vote is called, then the winning post is 13 votes.  So the straightforward scenario is one candidate gets 13 or more votes, and that’s job done. 

If nobody reaches a majority?
But if neither candidate reaches 13 votes, then the House will vote again.  This hasn't happened recently, but it's a possibility. If neither candidate gets 13 votes on the second time of asking, then the Speaker shall adjourn the House and call for fresh nominations. 
  • If there are no new nominations that day, then the House will be adjourned to the following day. 
  • If there are to be new nominations, then those plus a policy paper must be submitted at least an hour before the election sitting resumes and be circulated to Members. 
New candidates will be able to give a 10 minute speech, answer Members questions and give a closing speech prior to the next round of voting, but there are no hustings.

This process continues until someone gets the magic 13 votes.  Then there will a Confirmatory vote from the House that the Member be nominated as Chief Minister.

The decision as to who will lead the executive branch of government now rests in the hands of the Members of the House of Keys, and a nation watches.  We are watching the Members to see who is supporting who, who asks a probing and revealing question and which way they vote. We are watching the would-be Chief Ministers to see if they are suitable to be the figurehead of our nation, to represent us on the international stage and to lead an administration to maintain and support our quality of life.
​
What happens after the election sitting?
The winning nominee will be off to Government House to meet the Lieutenant Governor for formal appointment. And then they will need to appoint their Council of Ministers…
2 Comments

Who's for Speaker?

29/9/2026

2 Comments

 
Picture
Newly elected Keys Members will still be struggling to find their seat in the chamber as they're asked to make their first, and one of the most consequential, decisions,  who chairs the House for the next five years as Speaker. Under Standing Orders, candidates are proposed and seconded from the Members, there’s an election if there's more than one runner. It sounds procedural. It isn't. Get this wrong and every Keys sitting for the next 5 years is going to be harder than it needs to be.

The Speaker controls procedure, sets the order of business, and gives the authoritative interpretation of Standing Orders — including the unwritten conventions that never made it onto paper. It’s for this reason that it’s absolutely imperative that the Speaker is someone with experience of being in Tynwald. In Westminster, the Standing Orders are supplemented by Erskine May, a collection of precedents and customs.  The Isle of Man doesn’t have a similar reference and often Manx Presiding Officers will refer to Erskine May given the similarity in our parliamentary procedures.  But there's no substitute for experience.

The Speaker doesn't speak in debates in the Keys, but they decides who does, for how long, and on what. A weak or partisan Speaker doesn't just annoy the 'losing side'; they make the whole House look amateurish and can undermine the standard of debate, inhibit proper scrutiny and fester lasting divisions between Members. 

New Members should treat this appointment with the seriousness of a policy vote, not a formality to get through before the "real" business starts.

There are a few things worth thinking through before you back someone for the Speaker’s chair
  • Impartiality. Has this Member shown they can treat all Members the same way even when it's inconvenient to do so? A good campaigner is not automatically a good referee — sometimes the opposite.  Good campaigners tend to have quite definite positions and may well struggle to act impartially.
  • Command of procedure. The Speaker's rulings are final in the chamber; there's no easy appeal. Someone who already knows Standing Orders will save the House from confusion and from being quietly out-manoeuvred by Members who know the rules better than the Speaker does.  It’ll also prevent proceedings descending into chaos.
  • Respect for protocol. The Speaker should be someone who has demonstrated respect for the Standing Orders and for the Code of Conduct.  Beware any candidate who has fallen foul of the Tynwald Standards and Privileges Committee.  If they can’t follow the rules as a member, how can you be sure they will enforce them as Speaker?
  • Temperament under pressure. Firmness without heavy-handedness. Can they shut down a Member who's overrunning without turning it into a grudge match?  Can they protect Members right to speak and be heard, against those who would seek to disrupt them?
  • Willingness to give up the floor. The Speaker can't join debates in the House of Keys. That's a real sacrifice for anyone who came in wanting to argue policy from the backbenches — and a useful test of whether a candidate actually wants the job for the right reasons.
  • Leading the House. Since the Speaker also becomes Deputy President of Tynwald, the choice has consequences beyond the Keys alone.

It's tempting, especially for Members new to the chamber, to vote for whoever seems most senior, most familiar, or best liked personally. None of those are wrong instincts, but none of them are the job either. Popularity and impartiality aren't the same thing, and a well-liked Member who struggles to say no to friends may find the role harder than expected.  I expect the new Members have been in a bit of huddle over the last couple of days trying to work out their options.  I hope that they take a considered view rather than trying to indulge in some demonstration of force by nominating someone wholly unsuitable into the role.  We've heard much during the campaign about Members ability to work as a team for the good of the Island, and this is one of the first opportunities we will have to judge them on that.

The healthiest sign for the term ahead isn't a unanimous vote — it's a considered one. Members who can explain why they backed a candidate, beyond "they seemed like a good sort," are the ones who'll have grounds to hold the Speaker to that standard later if their rulings start to drift.
2 Comments

    Author

    I've has always been interested in politics.  I grew up in a household where canvassing for elections and knocking up the vote were frequent activities around election time. I regularly stay up until the early hours to wait for the results of significant elections.  In 2016 I joined Port St Mary Commissioners, and in 2021 I was elected to the House of Keys.  For over a decade I have written a scuba diving blog which blended science and diving with my experience and observations.  This blog allows me to share my views on politics in the Isle of Man.

    Archives

    October 2026
    September 2026

    RSS Feed

Dr Michelle Haywood​

Political Commentator
House of Keys 2021-2026

Contact

Tel: +44 (0)7624 300090
Email: [email protected]

​Published by Michelle Haywood, Marina House, Bay View Road, Port St Mary, IM9 5AQ.
Privacy notice · © 2026 Michelle Haywood
  • Home
  • From Rushen with love...
  • Media
  • About
  • Contact
  • Archive
    • 2026 Campaign >
      • 2026 Manifesto
      • Pledges
    • 2021 Archive